A water heater leak can quickly change from a small inconvenience to a full-blown emergency. If you’ve noticed puddles around your unit, weird noises, or less output of hot water, it’s probably time for a replacement. For homeowners in Tyler, TX, understanding what causes a water heater to leak – and knowing when to repair or replace – is essential for protecting your home and ensuring comfort.
At Benjamin Franklin Plumbing Tyler, we specialize in diagnosing and resolving leaks in both electric water heaters and gas units. Let’s dive into the common causes, repair options, and when to consider water heater replacement.
Water Heater Leak: Understanding the Problem
If you see water near your heater, it’s not always from the tank. The leak could originate from a number of different components. Before panicking, identify where the leaking water is coming from.
What Makes a Hot Water Heater Leak?
Corrosion
Over time, minerals from the water supply react with the interior of your water heater tank, leading to rust. Once corrosion begins, it’s often irreversible. Corroded tanks usually require full water heater replacement, especially if leaks are coming from the bottom of the tank.
Loose Connections or Fittings
The inlet and outlet connections that connect your water heater to the water line might get loose because of vibrations and wear on the connections. These leaks are often minor and can be fixed by tightening or replacing fittings.
Temperature and Pressure (T&P) Relief Valve Issues
The pressure relief valve is designed to discharge excess pressure. However, if the valve is faulty or if the unit is under excessive pressure, you might notice water dripping from the pipe attached to it.
Cracked Tank
A cracked tank is a more serious issue. Sudden changes in temperature or thermal expansion can lead to stress fractures. Unfortunately, these are typically not repairable.
Sediment Buildup
Hard water in Tyler often leads to sediment buildup at the bottom of the tank. This causes overheating, which can damage the tank lining and result in leaks.

Why Does Water Heater Leak From Relief Valve?
When the T&P valve is leaking, it’s essential to determine why.
Excessive Pressure
High pressure inside the tank—often due to overheating—forces the pressure relief valve to open and release water. This is a safety mechanism, but persistent leaking indicates a deeper issue.
Faulty Valve
Sometimes, the valve itself is defective. If replacing the valve stops the leak, you’re in luck. But if not, the pressure or temperature inside the tank may be too high.
Thermal Expansion
Water expands as it heats. Without an expansion tank, pressure can rise beyond safe levels, causing leaks from the relief valve.
Water Heater Replacement: When It’s Time for a New One
Repairing a leak is often possible, but sometimes replacement is the most cost-effective solution.
The Leak Is From the Tank Itself
A leaking water heater tank almost always signals the end of its life. Internal corrosion can’t be patched, and a full water heater replacement is necessary.
The Unit Is Old
If your water heater is over 10 years old, efficiency drops, and repairs become more frequent. In many cases, investing in a new unit saves money in the long run.
Frequent Repairs
If you have to repeatedly schedule water heater repair, or you are doing multiple DIY fixes on your own, consider the long-term value of a new, efficient unit. Frequent leaks indicate that your current heater is on its last legs.
Considering a Tankless Water Heater Upgrade
Tankless units offer energy savings and unlimited hot water. If you’re already facing a water heater leak, it might be the perfect time to look into upgrading to a tankless water heater.
Water Heater Leak FAQs
Yes, but use it with caution. If the leak is small and not directly from the tank, you can keep using cold water, but avoid hot water until you can get the water heater fixed.
It depends. If it’s a minor leak and it doesn’t involve electrical components, a quick shower may be okay. But if it’s leaking from electrical connections or the tank itself, you should avoid using hot water and call a professional immediately.
In many cases, yes. Leaks can worsen quickly and cause water damage, mold growth, or even electrical hazards. Call Benjamin Franklin Plumbing Tyler for prompt service.
If the drain valve or fittings are leaking, your unit may last several more years after repair. But if the water heater tank is compromised, it’s best to replace it immediately.
Not directly, but a malfunctioning gas heater leaking water might also have ventilation issues, which can lead to carbon monoxide exposure. This is a serious health risk and requires immediate professional attention.
Contact Benjamin Franklin Plumbing Tyler Today!
Don’t let a water heater leak disrupt your home or put your safety at risk. Whether you need a quick water heater repair, a full water heater replacement, or just an inspection, our certified plumbers are ready to help. We offer:
- 24/7 emergency plumbing services
- Transparent pricing and no hidden fees
- Expertise in both tank and electric water heater systems
- Options for tankless water heater upgrades
Located in Tyler, TX, Benjamin Franklin Plumbing Tyler is proud to serve our community with reliable, friendly service. We understand how stressful plumbing issues can be, which is why we show up on time, every time.
If you suspect a leak, don’t wait. Contact us today to schedule your water heater inspection and keep your home running smoothly.
Benjamin Franklin Plumbing Tyler serves the East Texas cities of Kilgore, Longview, Tyler, and Whitehouse with a team of certified plumbers. In addition to emergency plumbing repair, some of the plumbing services provided by the company include faucet repair, drain services, toilet repair, plumbing fixture installations, tub and shower installations, kitchen sink repair, faucet installation, water heater repair/replacement, and garbage disposal replacement. Call us today at (903) 730-6611 to schedule an appointment!